What if We Rewrite the Stars? (Part 5/9)

In my previous posts, I’m discussing the songs from The Greatest Showman and how each song portrays our relationship with the Lord. I’ve reordered the songs to tell a story about a man named James growing an intimate relationship with the Lord. Click the links below to read the previous posts:

A Million Dreams; Come Alive; The Other Side; Never Enough

In this post, we’ll discuss the lyrics from Rewrite the Stars. In Rewrite the Stars, God is explaining that James is the apple of His eye (Psalms 17:8 NIV; Deuteronomy 32:10 NIV), but James feels he does not deserve God’s love; ultimately not accepting the freedom God has given him.

Zac Efron and Zendaya are the singers of this song. For the explanation of the lyrics, when Zac Efron sings, that’s God speaking to James and when Zendaya sings, that James’ response to God.

God to James: You know I want you / It’s not a secret I try to hide / I know you want me / So don’t keep saying our hands are tied / You claim it’s not in the cards / Fate is pulling you miles away / And out of reach from me / But you’re here in my heart / So who can stop me if I decide / That you’re my destiny?

  • Explanation: This is so beautiful. God is basically saying James is the apple of His eye. There is nothing in this world James can do that will keep God from loving him. When He says, “I know you want me” that explains how James and everyone else in the world are looking for peace, love, and joy and God is the essence of that. We will experience this type of affection when we seek Him.


God to James: What if we rewrite the stars? / Say you were made to be mine / Nothing could keep us apart / You’d be the one I was meant to find / It’s up to you, and it’s up to me / No one can say what we get to be / So why don’t we rewrite the stars? / Maybe the world could be ours / Tonight

  • Explanation: It’s not too late for James to change his life around; it’s not too late to follow God. God is waiting on James and it’s up to James to make that decision. No one can force him. But God will always wait for James no matter how long it takes.


  • Explanation: It’s up to us to build that relationship with the Lord. Who cares what people will say about us? He is the Love you have been searching for throughout your journey on earth. Go to Him and don’t be afraid of what other people will think, and don’t think your past will keep you away from God. It won’t. He knew every single decision you would take on this earth before you were born and he still decided to create you. God is not going to give up on you. He loves you too much. So go to Him. He is waiting for you with open arms (Psalms 5:11-12 MSG; Jeremiah 29:13 NLT).


James to God: You think it’s easy / You think I don’t want to run to you / But there are mountains / And there are doors that we can’t walk through / I know you’re wondering why / Because we’re able to be / Just you and me / Within these walls / But when we go outside / You’re going to wake up and see that it was hopeless after all

  • Explanation: James believes his past aka “mountains” are keeping Him from experiencing God. Although James is able to express himself to God, He still doesn’t know how to live for Him. When it’s time to change the way James lives his life, he feels lost.

James to God: No one can rewrite the stars / How can you say you’ll be mine? / Everything keeps us apart / And I’m not the one you were meant to find / It’s not up to you / It’s not up to me / When everyone tells us what we can be / How can we rewrite the stars? / Say that the world can be ours / Tonight

  • Explanation: James believes because of his past or even because of family curses that repeat generation after generation, James feels he can’t change his life around aka “rewrite the stars” because he was “destined” to fail. But that is a lie. James was born for victory. He was born for something much greater than himself. James is allowing what others say and what the devil whispers in his ear to affect his life in a negative way—making him feel hopeless.
God and James to each other: All I want is to fly with you / All I want is to fall with you / So just give me all of you
James to God: It feels impossible (it’s not impossible) / Is it impossible?
  • God’s Explanation: God wants to be there for James through his ups and down if only James will let him in (Psalms 63:7-8 NLT).
  • James’ Explanation: I want you but living this life is hard and I feel my failures are pulling us apart. It feels impossible for you to love someone like me, but is it possible?


This picture exemplifies the relationship we have with God. God clings to us and we cling to Him through this crazy life we live; through all the ups and downs we experience. | Source: toofab
James to God: You know I want you / It’s not a secret I try to hide / But I can’t have you / We’re bound to break and my hands are tied
  • James wants God and God knows that but James is trying to fix his situations himself (“We’re bound to break and my hands are tied”) when really he should give all his problems and all his worries to God and allow God to handle everything.


Don’t ever think you’re forever damaged because of your past or even your current mistakes/failures. God loves you regardless of the mistakes you have made or the family you were born into. When we repent of our sins, God forgives and forgets (Hebrews 10: 17 NLT; ). “He has removed our sins as far from us as the east is from the west (Psalms 103:12 NLT). “When we release our worries and traumatic experiences, God will change those negativities into something beautiful (Isaiah 61:3). For us to love ourselves and others, we must first accept the love that God has for us. He is waiting for you to receive his peace, love, and joy with open arms. All you have to do is set your mind to believe in Him and surrender all your pain and worries to Him.


In the next post, we’ll discuss the song, This Is Me. In This Is Me, James has finally accepted his flaws and past and he will not allow them to block his blessings.


What’s your favorite song from The Greatest Showman and why? Leave your answer down below in the comments!



Posted by

Believer | Writer | Bibliophile | 1 Thessalonians 5:16-18

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.